Tall Tales and Lumber Sales

By Amanda Ross on May 26, 2009

When the Red River Lumber Company installed electrically operated mills in California, logs could be devoured "faster than a small boy devours a cookie."  At the prospect of keeping the mills supplied with enough lumber to match the incredible processing speed, logging contractors shook their heads and said, "Send for Paul Bunyan."  Or so claimed William B. Laughead, former lumberjack, artist, and freelance advertising man.

In 1914, Archie D. Walker, Secretary of the Red River Lumber Company, employed Laughead, his cousin, to develop an advertising campaign for the company's new Westwood, California mill.  As Laughead recalled in a FHS-sponsored oral history interview, Archie

... said that an idea he wanted to get over was that "we're operating in a big way out here so we have a big production, and it will be a reliable source of supply for wholesalers and buyers to hook up with. That's the idea that we've got to sell - not only to our old customers in the Mississippi Valley but the new territory we've got to break into, east on the Atlantic seaboard, that we've never had contact with before. We want them to know it's the same kind of pine that they've been using, and that we can handle business in a big way with a big manufacturing capacity out there." So I said to him, "That's kind of a big message to get over in a short time. Maybe we could get ahold of some kind of a slogan that would tie us up with the old traditions of the eastern white pine and carry them right over into the West. They're getting the same thing."

The two men tossed around ideas.  Finally, Walker suggested the folk hero Paul Bunyan, stories of whom circulated forestry camps, especially in the Great Lakes region.

Paul Bunyan first appeared in print in 1906 but languished in relative obscurity until Laughead's efforts for the Red River advertising campaign.  Reporter James MacGillivray had gathered stories from lumber camps and added his own touches, which eventually culminated in an unsigned story, entitled "The Round River Drive," that appeared in the June 24, 1910 Detroit News Tribune.  Four years later an unknown poet set MacGillivray's "The Round River Drive" to verse in the April 25, 1914 issue of American Lumberman magazine.  (More detailed coverage is available in "The First Paul Bunyan Story in Print" from the October 1986 issue of the Journal of Forest History.) Appearing only in local newspapers and lumber trade journals, the prose and verse forms of "The Round River Drive" recorded the Paul Bunyan legend for its traditional audience.

Laughead, however, has been credited with catapulting the little-known folk hero to American national idol.

FHS holds a copy of the rare first edition pamphlet, "Introducing Mr. Paul Bunyan of Westwood, California," in the William B. Laughead Papers. Laughead created the characters on the second row (left to right): Brimstone Bill, Big Joe, and Johnny Inkslinger.

Laughead had never read the MacGillivray's works or derivations of these early stories.  Independently, Laughead began developing a series of pamphlets in which Paul Bunyan tales and cartoons accompanied advertisements for the Red River Lumber Company's goods and services. A postcard-sized booklet Introducing Mr. Paul Bunyan of Westwood, California was published in 1914, and its companion Tales About Paul Bunyan, Volume II was printed just two years later.  Through his text and illustrations, Laughead made significant contributions to the Bunyan canon -- imbuing the legendary lumberjack with personality characteristics; defining Bunyan's iconic appearance; developing wholly new characters, including Babe the Blue Ox and Babe's custodian Brimstone Bill; and bringing minor characters into distincition, including the penny-pinching clerk Johnny Inkslinger and camp cooks Big Joe.

Booklets were mailed to the territory east of the Mississippi Valley.  The initial campaign did not go over well because, Laughead conjectured, Paul Bunyan was not well-known outside his region and outside the lumberjack camps.  Paul Bunyan did not resonate with lumber dealers or manufacturers, and most buyers threw away the early advertisement. As a result, first editions are rare collectors' items due to the immense popularity of Laughead's subsequent pamphlet.

In 1922, the company published The Marvelous Exploits of Paul Bunyan, a re-vamped version of Laughead's first work.  Although intended for the same specialized audience of lumbermen, this booklet unexpectedly had a more far-reaching impact.  A lengthy review of the pamphlet appeared in the Kansas City Star and this coverage introduced the legendary folk hero to the general public.  This new version was an instant success with the public, especially with children.  In the Journal of American Folklore, Max Gartenberg wrote, "Within a few months after its publication the entire edition of 10,000 copies was exhausted, and a reprint of another 5,000 copies could not satisfy the requests of children, teachers, folklorists, statesmen, librarians, soldiers, and sailors -- persons of all interests and walks of life..."

The popularity of the work necessitated the reproduction of new editions for years to follow, culminating with the Thirtieth Anniversary Edition of 1944.  This third advertising pamphlet was occasionally given other titles in subsequent reproductions, one of the most common being Paul Bunyan and His Big Blue Ox.  In 1957, Laughead commented, "My book went through a total of thirteen editions, and we distributed, free of charge, about 110,000 or 125,000 copies."

paul bunyan pine logoThe Red River Lumber Company capitalized on the increasing popularity of the Paul Bunyan folk legend by engaging Laughead as its full-time Advertising Manager.  The company officially adopted Paul Bunyan's name for use in its business dealings and copyrighted Laughead's illustration of Paul Bunyan's head, using it as a trademark for its products.

While the company embraced the logging salesman, newspapers across the nation printed columns of reader-submitted Paul Bunyan stories and syndicate-created tales.  As the tall tales stretched coast to coast, Paul the Lumberjack-Hero was dwarfed by Paul the American Spirit.  No longer restricted to the woods, Paul Bunyan became a legend of all regions.  Stories credited the lumberman with varied accomplishments, from digging the Puget Sound to succeeding as a Southwest oilman to building the Panama Canal.

As early as 1916, the legendary lumberjack received critical examination; the interest shown by folklorists and other scholars increased as Paul Bunyan captured the popular imagination.  Gartenberg concluded, "In due time poetry, plays, music -- the medium of almost every art -- explored the themes that had been made by the great advertisement.  And thus did a lumberman's advertising scheme become American folklore."

The Forest History Society is fortunate to hold the papers of William B. Laughead, which contain the works and illustrations seen in this post -- and much more.  The finding aid describes the collection in greater detail.

Information in this post was drawn from the articles referenced above as well as the following:

  • Max Gartenberg's article "W. B. Laughead's Great Advertisement," which was published in the October-December 1950 volume of the Journal of American Folklore (pp. 444-449).
  • The full text of the Forest History Society oral history interview with Laughead, which was conducted by W. H. Hutchinson on September 17-18, 1957.

0 responses to “Tall Tales and Lumber Sales”

  1. Nice summary of Laughead here.

    My forthcoming book puts Laughead’s Bunyan in context and documents the oral tradition for the first time. My book, Out of the Northwoods: The Many Lives of Paul Bunyan (http://www.wisconsinhistory.org/whspress/books/book.asp?book_id=348), will appear in October from the Wisconsin Historical Society Press. The story of Bunyan’s progress is actually much stranger, and more intriguing.

    One chapter from it is online here: http://content.wisconsinhistory.org/u?/wmh,49622 This briefly gives the pre-MacGillivray publications (Bunyan first appeared in print in Duluth in 1904 and reached a national audience in Feb. 1910, before the Round River articles in Michigan) but focuses mostly on Stewart and Watt’s research.

    Anyway, congratulations again on the nice blog post and the online register.

  2. Mr. Edmonds,

    I’m pleased you found the post interesting and I’m very glad for your additions to the story.

    If you are ever in the Tar Heel state, please consider visiting the Forest History Society in Durham, NC. We’ll be happy to show you the Laughead papers and any other materials you’d like to research: http://foresthistory.org/ead/

    Looking forward to your book!

    ~Amanda Ross, Project Archivist

  3. Love the blog. I run a chainsaw blog and I wish I could write like you! Great post!

  4. John McGee says:

    Thank you Amanda,

    I spoke with Mr. Lewis today in a nice chat about the content of your blog.

    I wanted to post a bit of a jot how I came to find your work.

    My avocation as a storyteller takes me through many venues of information, the internet being the fastest for quick reference that I can take time to verify as the need arises.

    I found your posted quote at the top by, I believe Mr. Laughhead to be wonderfully insightful, and wanted to make sure I had the correct source for a small presentation I’m doing tonight on Tall Tales in Sales.

    I have a few storytelling friends in the Washington Oregon area who keep me strait on logging and tree farming. It’s truly amazing how us “City folk” can show our ignorance and credulity which provide a constant temptation to the storyteller.

    Thank you for the entry, I’ll check back on a regular basis now to see further updates.

    All the best to you,

    John

  5. John McGee says:

    I stand corrected, the quote is by Edward Lear, an author and artist.

    Cheers,

    John

  6. Donna Ellis says:

    I have a copy of Paul Bunyan and His Big Blue Ox, 30Anniv. Wonder what its worth?

    • charles loeffler 340 larchmont spfld ohio 937 408 6322 says:

      dont know but i picked up a 1922 red river book in regards about paul bunyan

  7. Mountainman says:

    Well I live here in Westwood and believe that there is some kind of creature giant man at w****w lake bog, I was skeptic until I heard what some have seen!

  8. steve says:

    my wife just sold on ebay after reading to me the tales of p b post card book nice stuff